Fem seeds and there impact on the future of the species known as cannabis.

  • Thread starter Thread starter hempy
  • Start date Start date
I'm telling people to leave because they keep coming in and posting half truths or outright lies. Kind of like how removing the Y chromosome from our pool would destroy half of the genes available for breeders. That's a laughable notion.

Eliminating the Y chromosome does NOT eliminate half the pool. It eliminates the male chromosome, nothing else. And much of the Y actually recombines with the X so nice try but those genes are in females as well. You certainly aren't eliminating anything growers care about. The part of the Y that doesn't recombine is responsible for males, something I and drug cultivators in general don't even care to grow out.

I'm not smoking feral hemp because of PROGRESS. Progress through science. You know the same progress that so many in this community would stamp out due to a poor understanding of genetics.
 
I'm telling people to leave because they keep coming in and posting half truths or outright lies. Kind of like how removing the Y chromosome from our pool would destroy half of the genes available for breeders. That's a laughable notion.

Eliminating the Y chromosome does NOT eliminate half the pool. It eliminates the male chromosome, nothing else. And much of the Y actually recombines with the X so nice try but those genes are in females as well. You certainly aren't eliminating anything growers care about. The part of the Y that doesn't recombine is responsible for males, something I and drug cultivators in general don't even care to grow out.

I'm not smoking feral hemp because of PROGRESS. Progress through science. You know the same progress that so many in this community would stamp out due to a poor understanding of genetics.

do you know how meany of the legendary scientific mind were called liar and accused of preventing progress by the scientific community throughout history? most were called mad in there day with obscene ideas.

you know these people your speaking about are probably thinking the same thing about you as you are them GITT. some people think fairy's exist and well its not for me to tell anyone they don't just because i don't believe the same. i just don't have to believe them and have a difference off opinion.

as far as getting rid of the Y chromosome goes. how are you going to make seeds without it then? if it's not there you cant even make fem seeds. no mater what it has to be there dominant or not to make pollen even on a female plant.

where is this scientific progress then that made this good weed your smoking? last i checked most of the best strain on the market today are from the early 90's and before. made by crossing a male to a female just like people have done for thousand of years. nothing modern scientific progress about them.

i like most like to know more and find out more about cannabis on a genetic level. i like most read post for new ideas, theories and facts. then go and do abit of research to build up my own opinion of them. it might be the same it might not but its based on what i understand from what i know. if for example. i think the gene pool benefits from the Y chromosome and you don't i don't go and say. leave the thread GITT my opinions different. try discussing why your opinions different. if it doesn't change the other persons opinion then fine you have a difference off opinion. there's more then one person reading and you may just of changed someone else. who knows maybe this person who's opinion you just change will explain thing different to to me and change my opinion. understand what i am getting at?

it's like this you tell someone there wrong and should leave the thread. they do with there opinion. nothings changed they learned nothing more. you changed nothing and just made people feel unwelcome and some even feel to stupid to even try to understand and learn more.

or you could just try explaining why you have you different opinion nice and simple. you get the reply. i think your wrong we have a difference off opinion. you lost nothing you still have your opinion and they have there's yes? but this time you have all them people you made feel unwelcome reading why you have your opinion and the other person has there's. they will have a opinion and may even have the same opinion as you. that's more people with the same opinion as you some even researching to have a opinion and finding out even more about the thing they have a opinion on.

see the thing is opinions change all the time. the more people researching the same thing the more theory's of it. the more research done and understood= the more scientific progress. if your such a big fan of scientific progress don't limit it by making people not want to understand it. making them feel unwelcome or stupid that's my point. were all entitled to a opinion and the more opinion on something the better its generally understood by others.

i will let you in of something GITT i once believed in fairy's when i was younger. now my opinion change. its happens but simply telling me not to believe in them wouldn't make my opinion change. the fact i never seen one alive or dead and no one else i know or trust has seen one alive or dead changed my opinion. the facts as i know them see people don't believe everything they read. there opinion's are based on the facts they know and know one knows everything.;)
 
You make gynoecious seeds by reversing the sexual expression of a female through chemical treatments that upset the hormone system responsible for male differentiation and use her as a pollen donor.

It's been argued to death on these forums for over a decade. I'm amazed you're on page 126 of this thread and you don't even understand how they're made?

The issue is most of what I say isn't opinion, it's scientific fact.
 
Pussy Infection!!!

Nobody gives a shit. Start a gynoecious seed co. then smarty pants, invest everything you have in it...

Your a fool, maybe a tool also. Your reality does not exist throughout the world, real people actually grow cannabis and further more no one i know of shares your passion in the matter.

Do everyone a favor and fuck off, take kashrocks with you, i dont think i can stand to read either ones of your crap anymore. Its a drag man...Start a 'Days of our Lives' thread.

GITT lets keep this convo going over the next few years, i think it will yeild some interesting revelations. Lets call it "my pussy infection has gone wild"

We can still be freinds tho rite?:mad:
 
GreenintheThumb, I just went back and read through all your previous posts and you seem to have a focus on one or two threads, this one included: and ALL of your posts are passive aggressive or inciteful - and do NOT mistake that with insightful. I wonder what you are doing here other than shit stirring and being a general pain in the ass. I wish you would take your ball and go home and find some other forum to play games in. You spruik off about some aspect of your knowledge that you seem to think is worthy of humanity, but to tell the truth you bore me to tears and I am now putting you on ignore!
 
Last edited:
You make gynoecious seeds by reversing the sexual expression of a female through chemical treatments that upset the hormone system responsible for male differentiation and use her as a pollen donor.

It's been argued to death on these forums for over a decade. I'm amazed you're on page 126 of this thread and you don't even understand how they're made?

The issue is most of what I say isn't opinion, it's scientific fact.

yes mate i am on page 126 of this thread i have also read about as many pages all over the net on the subject if not more. the reason a female reverses sex is because they have the Y chromosome even if its not dominant. it can be made dominant through chemicals that block out things like copper protein cells that affect the plant ability to make hormones. its a environmental change that affects the plant on a cellular level. just like growing in a apple store will give you a higher level of females from regular seeds. you take them from the store and what you have is plants you thought were female going male.

its like this as i understand it your plant has both X,Y with fem seed you have Xy Xy giving you a over all expression of the X chromosome. because you still have the y chromosome it can be expressed as a plant determines it's sex not just from the XY chromosome but also other cells that effect hormone balance. that why a regular plant can express ether X or Y or even XY in the case of hermies because of a hormone producing balance on a genetic level.

when you make a fem seed from 2 females your doing something people have done for years (breeding by selection for females) what is a female? well as i see it it's a plant that expresses the X chromosome not one with only the X. it expresses the X because of factors on a genetic level before it even germinates. your not even breeding for the X chromosome its other genes your breeding for as well when you make fem seeds.

let's try explaining like this. why do plants hermie you have read at least 126 page's on hermies here you should have a idea? it's a hormone imbalance kind of like your plant having a switch when it's turned on it can make certain proteins to a high level and express X chromosome and you have a female plant with a lower level will be Y. now you have one that's just in the middle this one will expressed both X and Y it may start X then turn Y the reason it dose that is because of the environment your growing in affects how much of each protein is made.

now when you spray SN or what ever your stopping the plant making these proteins not its genes that actually make them. the result is a plant with a expression Y because of a temporary hormone imbalance but still carries all the genes that make it's original hormone levels that allowed it to express X. so through selection you have breed 2 plant that have a cellular make up to make enough of the protein that express X for the offspring to all express X. what you haven't done is breed out the Y it's still there and can be expressed.

now what if you breed a female to a plant that Hermie's? well you have your true female with a high protein level that affect hormones. you also have one that has a higher level then a male. one that was female flowered then thought its the end of the season and started shutting down after it flowered. it thinks its made its flowers for that season and is going to die because cannabis it a annual plant. its not made seeds and locks down the genes that effect hormone proteins in a effort to pollinate a near by female before it dies. so what you have is 2 plant that express X because of there genetic make up just like last time.

now let's go down the other road breeding hermies. you have a plant with a high enough hormone protein level to express X if its grown in the right environment. a little stress testing will reveal that environmental factors will easily bring it down to a level where it will not make enough to express X anymore and instead will express Y (hermie). breed 2 of these plant together and because of the amount of protein both parents make you will get mostly offspring with a protein level that can make them Hermie easy.

see as i see it you cant remove Y from the population it there in male and female cannabis plant. what the Y gene dose is slows down bottle necking imoa. i don't see fem seeds as bad if people that have them use them right and understand what they have. when people are selling them to people that don't know what they are and how they are breed. by which i am not just saying female to female plant all offspring are female.:rolleyes: half the people making them don't even understand that it's just a plant breed to have genes that make high levels of proteins that effect hormone production.

with a male female population thing are simple when it come to breeding you find a good male and female job done you can see with your own eyes how much protein the plants have pretty easily. with fems it's not quite that easy and you can also create inbreeding problem easily. you have the ability to self inbreed something you cant with regular seed's which can give other problem if abused.


also can i just say to others on here please don't give bad comments to GITT on this thread. i consider this site to be one where people can be civil with each other. what happens with bad apple? if you put one with others that are fresh it will make them all bad. some with people and its been happening to much lately here. time to rise above it folks. next time the bad apple comes rise above it and don't follow suit. it's time we all made mns forum a nice place to be again. pass on a smile there contagious to you know. try it next time you walk past someone give them a big smile and watch it pass on.

have a nice day GITT here a big smile for you pass it on for me.:) see i think your entitled to your opinion to just like everyone else. even agree in past with it just not all off it but that fine by me.;)
 
Females are XX, males are XY. Y is dominant over X. There is no XyXy types. When you reverse sex on an XX it does not mean it has some sort of recessive Y chromosome. It means you are inducing a transient phenotype. The reversal does not change the genes in any way. Therefore the progeny are solely XX and what we call gynoecious.

I think you're confusing a few things. The X and Y are the sex chromosomes and are responsible for sex determination. It's why when you run a large enough sample you find statistically equal males and females. Sexual differentiation is a separate process that can be effected by intersex genes or can be completely reversed by a chemical treatment that effects the plants hormone systems. I wouldn't relate the intersex genes to the X or the Y chromosome. It stands to reason that these genes are located on the autosomes (as far as I can tell there is zero sex linkage).

I would altogether ditch your XyXy types and denote intersex as a different designation unrelated to the true sex chromosomes which can be deduced by cytological methods (ie, you can physically see the difference in size/shape between the X and Y).

Here's a big smile back for you :)
 
Last edited:
fat girls shouln't eat lots of chocolate
or ride mopeds
for skinny girls both are fine.

Femmed seeds are great for some people, they serve a purpose, but they're not for everyone. If you want to make some seeds of your own, so for the price of one pack of seeds you can have a couple of hundred seeds, then dont pick femmed, or use a male from a non femmed line to make an outcross F1 gen from.
But for a guy growing a few plants who doesn't want to wait till they're sexed to know how many girls he has (accepting the answer may be 0), they're a great alternative.

It's all about selecting something that suits your circumstances, that's all.

But I'm afraid anyone thinking that fairies or Xy females are just a fact of life, I'm sorry but that's just not reality. While your XY MALE may show as female, thats only due to a defective Y chromosome, which has failed to supress the female genes present in the other chromosomes, and is in fact a hermie. Just as a faulty X will fail to supress the male genes in the other chromosomes. The problem is when breeding with these hermies, are you using a failed male or a failed female? Either way, its just best not to use them at all. But a solid XX FEMALE which has been feminised by using the pollen from a FORCED but solid separate XX FEMALE, is not harming the offspring generation, it is merely preventing it from being replicated in a way that would allow that line to breed naturally (in nature). So if we want to release our work into the wild at any point, then we need to use non femmed lines, if we want to breed within a line without buying chemistry sets, its best to avoid femmed lines, if we want to grow a few plants in a closet, and breeding isn't our aim, then femmed lines are doing us no harm at all.
 
Concluding statements.

Well in light of some of the things that have been said about me since I departed I feel I am entitled to a parting statement.

Before I go I just wanted to clarify a few things...


Selection is selection josh and we don't have to worry about the transient chemical treatments that induce sex reversal. It's a temporary change of phenotype that doesn't effect the genotype or progeny.


What a ridiculous statement!

Obviously it does effect the progeny, that is the main reason why people do it, so that they can acquire feminized seed, and so that they can breed exclusively with pistillate specimens. Selection is a problem as well because feminization does not work in truly homogametic diploid females. In order to “feminize” a plant, it must be a heterogametic specimen that expresses itself as solely pistillate, which means by definition, it must be tetraploid. So in choosing the path of feminization you are ultimately crippling yourself from the outset, because you must first select a tetraploid to breed with.


And you know they were probably doing fine smoking feral hemp but I prefer the resin of my modern cultivars.

Well it is good to hear that you actually do have cultivars, now we are getting somewhere, you are so good at cutting others down, and antagonizing and belittling those of us who are here to learn and teach.

You heckled Nevil so much that he actually left the very thread that he created for us on breeding techniques. What self respecting man would continue in the accusatory deprecating environment you created with your disruptive posts. And where is he now? I suppose it could be argued that you robbed all of us of a critical opportunity to learn from a master, which now, it appears we may never regain.

I think you owe us all an explanation: What exactly are your “modern cultivars”? they certainly must be spectacular, to make all other cultivars appear “feral” by comparison.
They say a picture is worth a 1000 words. Put out or get out, I believe the saying goes.
What exactly are you growing that prompts such unbridled arrogance and hubris? I think its time for you to put your money where your mouth is, and show us what you are cultivating that is so great, or else kindly be quiet, and leave the forum to those who have more to do on here than talk a bunch of hot air with nothing to back it up.
 
Last edited:
1) The chemicals do not effect the progeny. The reason the progeny is gynoecious is because you have SELECTED an XX individual and you won't find any XYs in the punnet square...I can't believe you don't understand this concept. It has dick all to do with tetraploids. Learn some basic genetics.

2) Who would continue to chat with me? People who are informed and have something to say. That's who. Sorry it apparently isn't Nevil.

3) I wasn't calling all modern cultivars feral. I was saying we've used science to progress from feral hemp to our modern varieties.

Know nothings don't get to tell me to leave josh. Crack a book and fuck off.
 
The message you have entered is too short. Please lengthen your message to at least 10 characters.
 
Last edited:
hey hempy ,,
just on advancements made ,
sometimes we need to go backwards a little to go fowards ,
im sure plenty of that goes on ..

imho we are beginning to understand things moreso now then ever before ,
the advancements will come im sure .
sometimes its 2 steps foward 3 steps back .. .
 
Personally I wouldn't advocate the practice of feminisation, however my objections are based on the fact that the males aren't being worked. The female side of the line is being worked, and feminising does nothing to harm that, poor selection of females may, however the process itself doesn't. The problems arise when re-introducing the male into the line (which to keep the line pure, would involve backcrossing to a male from an earlier generation). This then requires the line to be reworked and to me, this is merely repetition of work that could already have been done by simply avoiding the feminisation process to begin with. GiTT is right in what he says, and I can't see why Nevil would disagree with what GiTT has said, although I can see why Nevil would disagree with the principle.
 
1) The chemicals do not effect the progeny. The reason the progeny is gynoecious is because you have SELECTED an XX individual and you won't find any XYs in the punnet square...I can't believe you don't understand this concept. It has dick all to do with tetraploids. Learn some basic genetics.

2) Who would continue to chat with me? People who are informed and have something to say. That's who. Sorry it apparently isn't Nevil.

3) I wasn't calling all modern cultivars feral. I was saying we've used science to progress from feral hemp to our modern varieties.

Know nothings don't get to tell me to leave josh. Crack a book and fuck off.

look your really a peace of work GITT.:eek: your living in your own little world. yes there's no such thing as Xy. but i was trying to explain some thing i don't know how to wright down sorry you didn't understand it.:o thing is cannabis is not imoa a plant that is predominantly Dioecious. so sorry but imoa your going to be looking for a long time for your true female so in cannabis your not even going to get XX or a XY imoa. cannabis is Hermaphrodite or Monoecious just like hemp imoa. it can reverse sex based on environmental factors. maybe you can show me the symbol for a Hermaphrodite?;) the way i showed it was just to try show dominant expression of sex. so i could of done it this way with the same meaning yX.

sorry i don't know everything like you but then i don't believe that you do ether. your the only one that thinks your some kind of genius that knows everything regarding cannabis sex.

also i want to say there's no point replying because i am putting you on blocked so i wont be able to read your reply. this forum was made so people could come and learn not be told to [Crack a book and fuck off]. your everything this forum wasn't made for. for this reason you have no place in it imoa. so as i don't think you a valuable part of the forum and cant see you leaving it. i am removing you from is as i read it.

you as josh said have tried your best to make people feel unwelcome and contributed to one if not the best breeder in the history of cannabis leaving this site. what have you done so good well i dont see nothing but a big mouth. as far as i can see you haven't even grown a plant never mind anything else.

contributing isn't just saying it's like this you better believe me or leave. well maybe in you sad little self obsessed world. i tried being nice and even told others to try being nice to you but your a bad apple i see that now.:o so its time to remove the bad apple from my fruit bowl and i cant be bothered looking for the good bits anymore its time waisted imoa. yet i bet your little closed mind cant even understand the meaning of that statement anyway. so good by bad apple your gone from my life. i feel better for that already and i have that big smile on my face you posted back to me so thanks for that anyway. sarcasm or not it still made me smile so it worked just like i told you it would.:)
 
Last edited:
fat girls shouln't eat lots of chocolate
or ride mopeds
for skinny girls both are fine.

Femmed seeds are great for some people, they serve a purpose, but they're not for everyone. If you want to make some seeds of your own, so for the price of one pack of seeds you can have a couple of hundred seeds, then dont pick femmed, or use a male from a non femmed line to make an outcross F1 gen from.
But for a guy growing a few plants who doesn't want to wait till they're sexed to know how many girls he has (accepting the answer may be 0), they're a great alternative.

It's all about selecting something that suits your circumstances, that's all.

But I'm afraid anyone thinking that fairies or Xy females are just a fact of life, I'm sorry but that's just not reality. While your XY MALE may show as female, thats only due to a defective Y chromosome, which has failed to supress the female genes present in the other chromosomes, and is in fact a hermie. Just as a faulty X will fail to supress the male genes in the other chromosomes. The problem is when breeding with these hermies, are you using a failed male or a failed female? Either way, its just best not to use them at all. But a solid XX FEMALE which has been feminised by using the pollen from a FORCED but solid separate XX FEMALE, is not harming the offspring generation, it is merely preventing it from being replicated in a way that would allow that line to breed naturally (in nature). So if we want to release our work into the wild at any point, then we need to use non femmed lines, if we want to breed within a line without buying chemistry sets, its best to avoid femmed lines, if we want to grow a few plants in a closet, and breeding isn't our aim, then femmed lines are doing us no harm at all.

i agree with you and thanks for explaining it like that. sorry i couldn't wright it as simple as you. i used Xy only as a way of showing dominant expression. i should off pointed that out. one question how would you describe a plant that starts it's life male them turns Hermie than goes completely female? would this plant be XX or XY? it started XY but later turned totally XX or it could of started XY then turned XX. were do these plant sit in regard to XY or XX?

i have heard of these plant lots and have a shit here that started XY but now it's XX without chemicals of any sort so is it XY because it started that way or is it XX because it shows no male flower expression now? as its not Hermie now i don't see how i can call it one. it's female even if it started male it has no male flowers at all on it now. i will take cutting from it soon and i don't think they will be Hermie or male. were dose this plant sit in regard to X's or Y's? see it's not simple to explain it that way so i compromised best i could.

i cant believe you don't believe in fairies GMT.:eek: what about Santa? surely he's real?:D
 
one question how would you describe a plant that starts it's life male them turns Hermie than goes completely female? would this plant be XX or XY? it started XY but later turned totally XX or it could of started XY then turned XX. were do these plant sit in regard to XY or XX?

A plant with a low threshold for stress. it still is what it started as!.
 
You heckled Nevil so much that he actually left the very thread that he created for us on breeding techniques. What self respecting man would continue in the accusatory deprecating environment you created with your disruptive posts. And where is he now? I suppose it could be argued that you robbed all of us of a critical opportunity to learn from a master, which now, it appears we may never regain.

IMO whats good for the goose is good for the gander. personally I like nevs views and there is nothing wrong with disagrement, none of us are perfect.. i'd personally like his dialogue on whittling down selection from lines...
 
Last edited:
Seems like lots of people are getting sick of greeninthearse's arrogance and offensive attitude.

Like hempy said, who are you and what have you bred?

If you don't have the experience then STFU, the way you treated Nevil who does have the experience is quite frankly, disgraceful.

Why is it people like greeninthehead who have some book learning always seem to tear into those who prefer actual hands-on experience to theory read from a book?
 
Can I suggest that you all also put Greeninthethumb on ignore like I have. Eventually he will end up talking to himself. It serves no purpose to again have a thread filled with vitriol. ;)
 
Seems like lots of people are getting sick of greeninthearse's arrogance and offensive attitude.

Like hempy said, who are you and what have you bred?

If you don't have the experience then STFU, the way you treated Nevil who does have the experience is quite frankly, disgraceful.

Why is it people like greeninthehead who have some book learning always seem to tear into those who prefer actual hands-on experience to theory read from a book?

I personally think GitT fights fire with fire, nothing wrong there... without theory and peers correcting you how do you know you are right? or moving in the right direction? with that sort of attitude children don't need school but should be happy in the sand pit for the rest of their lifes? some to me simply don't get some things.. I guess GitT gets a lil frustrated at times...
 
Back
Top